Perry Wolff

Apr 112017
 

Michael Redgrave

World War II had ended eleven years earlier, and Vietnam was yet to come.

The emotions of our victory had lessened and faded.

The fateful style of the commentators of World War II gave to simpler voices in the ‘50’s. Yet there were moments of heightened prose that could not be forgotten. Winston Churchill’s most famous lines are in the iambic mode: (short long, short long, short long): Shakespeare’s meter, Christopher Marlowe’s mighty line.

Read aloud and parse these excerpted passages from Winston Churchill’s speech, “This was their finest hour,” on June 18, 1940.

“…the Battle of France is over.

The Battle of Britain is about to begin.””

“The whole fury and might of the enemy

Must very soon be turned on us.

Hitler knows that he will have to break us in this island

Or lose the war. If we can stand up to him, all Europe may be free

and the life of the world

may move forward into broad sunlit uplands.

But if we fail,

Then the whole world,”…”including all that we have known and cared for,

will sink into the abyss of a new dark age.””

“Let us therefore brace ourselves to our duties

And so bear ourselves that

If the British Empire and its Commonwealth

Last for a thousand years, men will still say,

This was their finest hour.””

It was only later that I learned an actor had imitated Winston Churchill’s voice, and the Prime Minister’s speech was edited and shortened by the BBC. I tried to match the iambic prose as unobtrusively as possible. I didn’t want Cronkite’s accent, but in homage I wrote five beats to the line.

I asked Sir Michael Redgrave to read the forty lines of narration that had taken me a month to write. At the recording session, Sir Michael was very much affected by Churchill’s speech, and by his memories of the siege of Britain. Too much emotion—he cried.

I have never been good at directing actors.

I pleaded. “You know, Sir Michael, I think it would be better if you were … say … to hold it a little closer to yourself, say I mean, thin-lipped a little more, if you please? Please!”

That fine actor looked at me benignly and then wrote a single word on his script. His performance improved considerably but it had nothing to do with my direction.

Later I found the one word he had written:

OLIVIER

 

Image

Michael Redgrave, undated photo, http://vivandlarry.com/classic-film/spotlight-michael-redgrave/

Mar 282017
 

“You are finished at the Museum,” Sig Mickelson said. “We have a disaster on our hands with the Air Force. Be at my office at 8 tomorrow. Do you know Walter Cronkite?”

Mickelson had received orders from Bill Paley (his boss’s boss). I saw I was not to question him too closely.

Paley had been only an honorary colonel in World War II while Robert Sarnoff, the head of RCA-NBC, had been a full general. Two years earlier Sarnoff-NBC had done a twenty-six part series on the exploits of the United States Navy called Victory at Sea. It had been brilliantly produced and edited, with a score by Richard Rodgers. Paley-CBS called it Victory at NBC and in retaliation commissioned a series on the exploits of the United States Air Force called Air Power.

Air Power had not yet flown. A production staff of twelve, editing rooms, and tens of thousands of feet of stock footage were on 45th Street, unused. After a desk was reserved for the Air Force officer who acted as liaison, the staff became eleven.

I later learned Ed Saxe had recommended my predecessor for the job. Saxe was the CBS Vice President who had helped set up the administrative structure of the CIA. My CIA-approved predecessor had developed a brain tumor and had to be replaced for health and financial reasons. Mr. Paley wanted Air Power to be broadcast as soon as possible and the correspondent had to be Walter Cronkite, who had just become the anchor of the CBS Evening News. I asked if I might have Charles Collingwood. He and I had worked well together for almost three years. Or, given the time pressure, Edward R. Murrow, the most distinguished war correspondent in the history of radio.

Cronkite, said Sig’s face.  I learned later that CBS News was trying to get rid of Murrow’s boys. They were radio and they were World War II. Airtime had changed. Portentousness was giving way to sincerity.

Walter invited me to visit his home. He showed me a volume of the stories he had filed as a correspondent in Europe. He didn’t ask about my war experiences. I didn’t like to talk about combat and he had seen almost none. Once, he had jumped in a ditch under fire and there had been other close calls, he told me. I nodded. “Scary.” I suppose had I shown more admiration, even servility, he might have become friendlier, but things would worsen between us for the rest of my professional life at CBS News.

There was the matter of the Cold War. I learned much later that one of my principal researchers was a government plant. George Vicas never admitted it to me, although we became good friends. He spoke perfect Russian and his research papers were balanced and thorough. (In the 1980s the CIA sent him to Russia to make films in Russian to teach proper jurisprudence procedures to ex-Soviet court officers.)

Air Power was the first documentary series to be sponsored fully by one advertiser. They sent no memos or suggestions. If they had problems with the more controversial programs, I did not hear about it. The problems were between the correspondent, the Pentagon, and me.

The first film, the pilot to the whole series, was titled Target Ploesti. Ploesti was a Rumanian oilfield essential to German rolling and flying stock.

On August 1, 1943, 177 Air Force bombers in a surprise raid took off from North Africa to destroy the oilfields from low altitude. The target was 2700 miles away. The lead navigator made a mistake and flew directly over the German Air Defense Command headquarters in Bucharest. All surprise was lost. Ploesti was the worst defeat ever suffered by the United State Air Force. The footage of the raid was breathtaking. The bombers came in at one hundred feet, and cameras recorded the fighting. One bomber broke up directly before a camera and plunged into an oil refinery tower. No one could have survived the explosion.

The word “oil” was the key to the whole film. When Cronkite read my script he pronounced it in two syllables.

“Oy-yul “

“Walter, one syllable. Oil”

“That’s what I said. Oy-yul.”

“Oil”

“Oy-yul. That’s the way I say it; that’s how I say it.”

The tone was fierce, the glance dismissive. For that matter he dismissed the whole production, and never once came to the editing rooms. He was not yet the most trusted man in America. When later I had serious troubles with the Pentagon, I sent several drafts to his office for comment, but they were never acknowledged or returned. Walter was never made available to me. I turned his voice-over recording sessions over to an associate. He read what I wrote, without changes.

Cronkite never tried to contact me. Instead, as if Air Power were a theatrical production, he sent his two agents, Jap Gude and Tom Stix, to see me and to plead that I give their client more attention. One of the agents was drunk. I asked why Walter wouldn’t come to the office and help me.

“Do you know who he is? Walter is the star of the show.”

“If your client is the start of the show, why won’t he help me with the Air Force brass? They hate what I’m doing.”

“Cronkite is the anchor on the evening news, and that keeps him in New York all day long.”

“Tell him it’s his name on the front credits and get out of here.”

Target Ploesti became a shouting match when I presented it for comment to the public relations head of the Air Force. Robert L. Scott was an Air Force ace who had made many kills in World War II. He was a Flying Tiger, an authentic hero and a general who had written God is My Co-Pilot, later made into a movie.

I explained the architecture of the series. “The Air Force rises from defeat to victory, sir. You lose at Ploesti, you lose at Schweinfurt, and we lose at Pearl Harbor. We rise and win the war. Honesty is good dramatic construction.”

General Scott would not look at me. The projection room had a half dozen commissioned officers seated in it.

“Why would CBS put a foot slogging enlisted infantryman in charge of this series? What ever happened to the other producer? I flew him for a weekend in Mexico City. I thought we put somebody helpful in that office.”

God did not fly in the pilot’s seat. Scott had the stick and rudder; God was in the right seat where He could only be the co-pilot.

The Air Force was to be the star of the show. They had an agent, too. I found our liaison Air Force colonel rifling my desk. He was looking for the proposed outlines for other chapters. I took his keys from him and told him to get out of my sight. He left me a script written by my predecessor. It was marked “approved script” and signed by an assistant to Colonel Scott. Its theme was that the United States Air Force made no mistakes at Ploesti. I took the revisions to the head of CBS News. No self- respecting journalist or documentarian could accept their propaganda. Either CBS controlled the final scripts or the Air Force did.

Our lawyers were called in. The contract did not specify who had the final word. The assumption was that the series would follow NBC’s prize winning Victory at Sea. Both the network and the military would work together in common purpose. However in Victory at Sea the United States Navy never suffered a defeat after Pearl Harbor. It did take losses now and then. Ploesti was a defeat, not a loss.

Sig Mickelson, then President of CBS News, read the Pentagon’s version of the raid. He asked for time to work it out. It was never worked out, merely compromised. Fifteen years later in a broadcast I supervised, The Selling of the Pentagon, this conflict became the basis of the argument of whether the First Amendment guaranteed television the same rights as the print press.

Ploesti was an example of the paradox of war: How many should be asked to die for a target? Normally a ground force calls off an attack when casualties reach five percent. Elite corps like the Marines or SS will go to fifteen percent. The USAF took thirty percent in long raids deep in German territory. One out of three planes was lost on this August 1943 mission. Over 800 airmen were killed, wounded or missing. It was estimated that to stop the flow of oil from this source, at least seven more missions would have to be launched.

There were fifteen drafts of Target Ploesti. It was screened five times at the Pentagon and rejected each time. After the last screening Colonel Pitchford, the new liaison officer, was comforting.

“Look, here’s the deal,” he said. “The Air Force will transfer Scott off the project. The series is more important than he is. You’ll have another session. Make a change or two and wait.”

I compromised. I wrote a summary page explaining that the loss of oil helped us defeat Germany. Pitchford’s counsel was right. “The last page is Pentagonese and unintelligible.”

Cronkite read what was written and showed up late for the small banquet in the Pentagon.

Sometime later I went to see my brother, Leon Wolff, 2d Lieutenant United States Air Force, retired.

After my broadcast, Leon wrote a book on Ploesti, Low Level Mission. It was not a success but it was a far more detailed account than mine. But the record couldn’t be straight for either of us. For the next thirty years the Army hid the documents we should have seen. We both got it wrong. There is still the suspicion that the Germans had been tipped off by their intelligence agents in Libya.

The military reckoned that the value of the target was worth the number of the deaths. That’s a reckoning they never make in public.

The Air Force had put at my disposal an old twin-engine bomber with a crew on a standby basis. Colonel Pitchford was more given to wine and women than spying or propaganda. He was in the midst of divorcing a wife and on his way to a retirement and the real estate business. He came with an enlisted woman who was his aide.

The A-20 had a bomb bay that extended into the fuselage and was covered at the top. A mattress could be placed on the top of the bomb bay. I never used it, but the Colonel did and his Air Force lady did.

This twin engine plane had a second mattress in the plastic nose. While the pilot flew at low altitudes I could lie on it and watch America go by, a few hundred feet beneath me. I buzzed the nation, coast to coast.

It took two and a half days in those propeller-driven times. That low-level mission changed my professional life. It made me skeptical about unity and the co-axial cable, and satellite America.

America is a continent, not just a country. Television and mass marketing have forced us into a sense that we are small. It is so easy to switch pictures from coast-to-coast and border-to-border that in our collective mind the size of our continent is forgotten. We think of ourselves in terms that make us Lilliputian. We are not quintuple England or eight times France: all one has to do is fly low and slow from one coast to another. The United States is vast and varied and unpredictable.

I was astounded, and I still am.

In these jet days, when the flight attendant asks us to draw the shades so we can see a movie, I rebel. I keep the shade open and look down at our history; the land is our story. In the east, the patterns of agriculture curl and twist in the same manner as old Europe. In Indiana and Ohio come the squares of farming, subdivided land grants; the work of Thomas Jefferson. Each land grant tied to an educational institution. The squares are less subdivided in the Midwest. They stretch on and dissolve into the rivers and mountains that recall Lewis and Clarke. The deadly deserts of the Hopis and Navajos. The Rockies and then the Pacific. And as vast and diverse as the geography are the people. We are not one. We are a diverse multitude. In unity there may be strength, but in diversity there is survival.

 

Image

Air Power DVD, Amazon.com

 

Mar 272017
 

Our offices were in a turret on the south side of the building. Our film editing room was on the fifth floor of another section of the building, so it was a long walk between the two. Late at night the return took me through halls where work lights illuminated shards of far-off tribes; long dead beasts, artifacts of cultures I never knew or could ever know.

On one wall an accident of light fell on a large coiled tile. It was a ceramic spiral, a time clock showing the history of life on earth. At one minute to twelve Man entered life on this planet. A tiny tile in green represented some fifty thousand years in a three-billion-year whirl. Enter Homo sapiens, sapiens. Man who knows he knows.

I was nothing, a speck of dust in the last groove of the spiral.

Aeschylus wrote, “Wonders there are many, but none more wonderful than man.”

Newton wrote, “I do not know what I may appear to the world, but to myself I seem to have been only like a boy playing on the seashore, and diverting myself in now and then finding a smoother pebble or a prettier shell than ordinary, whilst the great ocean of truth lay all undiscovered before me.”

A museum is a walled collection of death.

During World War II, I had known the fear of death, but death came wrapped in panic. The beet field, the chicken coop, and Lipsky were mortality wrapped in terror. But the end did not arrive. It would later, but I stopped thinking about it once I was out of danger. Death went far from my mind.

In the Hall of the Incas, traversing the Hall of the Mammals, walking through the Birds of the Pacific, mortality surrounded me. Among the Jurassic Dinosaurs the bones were startling, but the blanket of death was larger than Tyrannosaurus Rex.

Dr. Simpson’s argument, Darwin’s thesis; life cannot progress unless there is death. Even the smallest unicellular paramecium dies when it reproduces. The cell that was one has become two; though the individual has reproduced itself, the original cell is gone. The overriding natural law in the study of natural history is that all living things must lose their lives.

That is why we are all mad.

We know this first premise of natural law, but for us to survive, the law of universal death must be forgotten—or daily life is impossible. Sanity is retained only if our inevitable and logical end is put aside, forgotten. For thinking man, madness restores common sense.

The second law of natural history is that the old must breed the young. Once the old have spawned they are sometimes permitted to live longer, but nature has little use for them. It is youth that is urged on with the sensual glories of sexual reproduction.

Nature demands death, but death must be preceded by reproduction. To bring new life is the duty of the old organism.

The evolutionists say that natural law demands death so that certain of the young will adapt better to a changing environment. Homo sapiens could not have evolved had the lesser hominoids not mutated in reproduction and produced modern man.

The duty, necessity and fierceness of the law of reproduction are inflexible. Reproduce, and then die is the totality of natural law. This is too cruel for the religious who demand that the Universe give Man an immortal soul.

The anthropologist Earnest Hooten noted that God could have placed the soul in man anytime He chose. He chose to give a soul to Homo sapiens, and not to the earlier hominoids.

For the evolutionist, and for the American Museum of Natural History, the immortal part may be the calcium deposit in the bones and teeth.

I did not like that last walk from the editing tower to my room in the turret overlooking West 73rdd Street. I did not want to be reminded that I would die someday.

I came back that midnight to find a note: “Call Sig Mickelson (my boss) whenever you get this.” I called.

 

Mar 202017
 

George Gaylord Simpson

One of the most ambitious series-within-a- series was a four-part summary entitled, The History of Life on Earth. The guide was George Gaylord Simpson, one of the world’s leading paleontologists and the author of The Meaning of Evolution.

Dr. Simpson began with fossil invertebrates seen under an electron microscope. With the aid of other curators we traced the tree of life to the arrival of man. We spent two hours explaining a half billion years.

Dr. Simpson was a man of sharp wit—when there were almost no letters of protest to his presentation of the theory of evolution he noted, “They don’t teach evolution the way they used to.”

The department of paleontology mounted the dinosaurs in the American Museum’s most visited hall. The joints of Tyrannosaurus Rex showed great deposits of calcium. We got a nice close-up of an arthritic bone that was 175 million years old. Undoubtedly the species suffered from the aching disease. The Kings of the Jurassic may have hobbled, rather than leapt.

Adventure never attracted a major audience, but some members of the Institute for Advanced Study at Princeton watched the program.  Dr. Albert Einstein told one of our contacts that he found Dr. Simpson stimulating. The suggestion was made that the German scientist would be willing to exchange views with Dr. Simpson on our program. The leading historian of time and space would meet a leading historian of the history of life.

Albert Einstein

America had a problem with the most famous physicist of the 20th Century. The FBI had a file of some 1500 pages alleging that he was not only a Communist, but had raised money for Communist organizations. Einstein was a certified and dangerous Red. Some of the FBI sources were prostitutes the scientist had allegedly used.

CBS itself was under attack from government committees, sponsors and affiliated stations, and had drawn up a blacklist, but it was inconceivable that Albert Einstein would be prohibited from appearing. I went to my boss and the decision was that if Einstein wanted to talk politics, the moderator would be Edward Murrow; but if he wanted to speak about science the program’s host, Charles Collingwood, would be the anchor.

I thought it only fair to inform the American Museum that the great scientist was a possible guest.  The Chairman of the Board was Alexander White, of White, Weld & Co, a leading Wall Street financial house.

Mr. White told me that he would not have that card carrying communist on a program coming from his Museum of Natural History.

I asked for his refusal in writing on the Einstein matter. He never sent it.

I heard later that Dr. Simpson attended two lunches with Albert Einstein.

 

Images

George Gaylord Simpson, undated photo, http://palaeoblog.blogspot.com/2011/06/born-this-day-george-gaylord-simpson.html

Albert Einstein, undated photo, http://philadelphia.cbslocal.com/2015/03/17/scientists-celebrate-albert-einsteins-birthday/

 

 

Mar 162017
 

Hollyhock House

One of the glories of the American Museum of Natural History was the Hall of Mexico and Central America. As part of the Adventure Series (1953-1955), we planned a lengthy segment on the films a staff archeologist had taken of Mayan architecture. He would then have a conversation with Frank Lloyd Wright, the American architect.

An enormous blowup of Hollyhock House, one of Wright’s major achievements, was placed next to a model of Mayan architecture. Wright had suggested the photographic similarities to the research staff. He had just begun what would become the Guggenheim Museum in New York.

Wright had written extensively on the relationships between his architecture and Mayan step design. After a discussion with him our researchers brought him a summary of the areas he and Charles Collingwood might discuss.

Wright appeared—distinguished, elegant, reserved—and requested no one talk to him while he prepared. He sat next to my wife, and as I passed by, I heard this unsteady exchange:

“How do you like television, Mr. Wright?” Tuulikki asked.

“How to you like being a wife?”

Gordon Eckholm, the anthropologist, spoke about the studies he had made on Cortez, and Charles introduced Wright.

I was the camera director. The opening shot of the segment was to be a gradual pullback from the Mayan piece and Wright’s famous Hollyhock House, ending in a picture of the narrator and his guest.

During the reveal Charles asked, “Sir, would you tell us the relationship between the Mayan tradition and your splendid work?’

“No relationship at all, Mr. Collingwood! No relationship! Nothing Mayan about my work!”

That was not at all what he had told our research staff. He was drunk. Embarrassingly drunk.

There was an unlit great hall to the right of the Hall of Mexico where a gigantic blue whale hung from the ceiling. That’s what caught Wright’s eye.

Whale at Milstein Hall of Ocean Life, AMNH

He staggered out of camera and microphone range and disappeared to look at a stuffed monster on the ceiling of the next hall. “A whale in the sky! What a wonderful idea.”

He slapped a column on the way out. “What a wonderful architectural erection!”

My floor director, Joseph Papp, tried to head him off but I told Joe to let him go. I asked the technical director to close all microphones and pictures.

Collingwood was wearing a headset, and I asked him to vamp. Charles, ever supple, turned to Dr. Eckholm and asked why Mayan culture had disappeared. Eckholm was modest, interesting, and went on to discuss the decline of Inca culture.

No one paid attention to the revered and drunken architect.

While the Wright kinescope still exists, the Museum archivists have held it from biographers of the architect. Recording tape did not exist so that the only records are motion picture films in black and white taken from the TV output—kinescopes.

The Museum subsequently published a catalog of the kinescopes of the series. CBS junked its copies.

From the Museum’s catalog: “Cue cards fell over the camera lens, a gorilla went out of control, rattlesnakes did not stay in their marks, and interviewees extemporaneously contradicted the host.” Nevertheless the series and I won Peabody Awards.

 

Image

Hollyhock House,  https://www.pinterest.com/pin/253397916505706050, originally published in architecture. about.com, article by Jackie Craven, November 13, 2008

Whale at Milstein Hall of Ocean Life, AMNH, http://www.amnh.org/exhibitions/permanent-exhibitions/biodiversity-and-environmental-halls/milstein-hall-of-ocean-life

 

 

 

Mar 012017
 

Black History: Lost, Stolen or Strayed (1968); narrated by Bill Cosby, co-written by Andy Rooney and Perry Wolff, produced by Perry Wolff

At WBBM I was also assigned public interest “sustainers” or unsponsored programs. In the 40’s the commercial broadcasters were required to do public interest programming or face the threat of their license being given to someone else. A license to broadcast was a license to print money. Nevertheless almost nothing was spent on “sustainers.” I directed a series entitled, Democracy USA, which fictionally detailed the accomplishments of American Negroes, as they were called at the time: Harriet Tubman, and heart surgeons Ulysses Grant Dailey and Daniel Hale Williams. I directed and co-wrote with Dick Durham, the editor of The Chicago Defender, the leading black newspaper in Chicago.

Part of the arrangement between the radio station and The Chicago Defender was that I would write a few words in their newsroom about race relations. As the only white in the newsroom I was uncomfortable in their premises and they were too.

I submitted a few hundred words of copy to the editors. At the end of the first day Durham asked me to leave for good.  When I asked why, he and two others pointed out that in my copy I had not capitalized the “n” in Negro.

The Chicago Defender was a one day gig in 1947.

Democracy USA was a thirteen-week series. Durham wanted no whites to interfere with the writing and production, including me.  He quit and took the series to a competitive local station.

I was blacked out. Or whited out.

In 1968 after the murder of Martin Luther King, I did a series, Of Black America. With the help of researchers I wrote the first episode, Black History, Lost, Stolen and Strayed.  It later won many awards. When I first presented it to one of Bill Cosby’s staff, he read it and stared at me.

“You didn’t write this script.”

“I did.”

“You couldn’t have.” It was an accusation, not a compliment. I could not be that accurate and perceptive.

I had been whited out again.

At first Cosby was distant. Later, the reviews were so complimentary about Black History, Lost Stolen and Strayed he called me and asked if he could do another episode in the series. I flew to England where he was filming. He narrated my script for The Black Soldier without submitting it to his informal black advisors. He trusted me.

Other blacks didn’t.

At an award dinner honoring the broadcasts I was seated among a number of blacks and whites when I overheard the following:

“As for the Hebes, the problem is that they look like every other white. So they pass for white. But they are different.”

“Right on, man.”

This time I hadn’t been whited out. I had been Jewed out.

 

Image

Black History: Lost, Stolen or Strayed (1968), https://www.rottentomatoes.com/m/black_history_lost_stolen_or_strayed/

Feb 282017
 

Samuel Barber, 1944

The fifth floor of the Museum housed the scientists’ offices and was also a storehouse of artifacts not on display. Margaret Mead had contributed objects from her work in Bali. While she and I were working out a script for the segment on Manus she pointed at something I had never seen. She called it a saron. It looked something like our xylophone, but the keys were brass and there was a trough under it for resonance.

“Can you play it? “

“No. We’ve got a lot of musical instruments in the collection. We’ve never heard them played. “

We found a number of sound makers that had been collected but never used by the museum’s staff. One of Jac Venza’s friends was Samuel Barber. I had heard of Barber who belonged to the short list of serious American composers. When we met he was shy and terse with me. I think he was uncomfortable with straight men. I would ask a question but he would direct his answers to Jac.

Curiosity overcame his modestly when he touched the artifacts. He and Jac whispered and then told me they would return in a week or two. On an April day he brought some first chair musicians from the New York Philharmonic. The flutist picked up a wooden Japanese wind instrument and compared its primary scale against the conventional Western flute.  It was a different do-re-mi than our diatonic scale.

The first chair trumpeter tested a Fiji Island conch shell and a horn made of calabash sections from Tanganyika Africa.  The percussionist examined a two toned drum in the form of a slit wooden animal. One side of the carving gave one tone; the other, a lower timbre. The talking drugs from the Yoruba were mobile tympani. The tribal drums were held under the armpit. When the elbow squeezed the drum into the rib cage the tone ascended or descended.

A palm sized metal instrument best described as a hand piano that twanged when plucked fascinated Samuel. He opened his composition with it.

The composer was restricted by budget to six musicians. He did not want to compose for the artifacts alone. His musicians would also use the conventional harp, French horn and clarinet.  He waived his fee to hire a seventh musician.

Barber wrote a twenty-minute score for Adventure that could not be conventionally notated. It was exotic, beautiful and inventive. His biographers have found Barber’s written score, but it can never be replayed.

 

Image

Samuel Barber, by Carl Van Vechten – Van Vechten Collection at Library of Congress, Public Domain, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=52003

 

Feb 272017
 

Center to Right: Perry Wolfe, Jac Venza and Mike Wallace, CBS Adventure Series

When television was young—before the computer, the microchip, and editing cuts lasting less than a wink—CBS News did 136 broadcasts of Adventure, a documentary television series beginning in 1953. It was produced in collaboration with the American Museum of Natural History and hosted by Charles Collingwood.

Some programs had no commercials. The salesmen called Sunday afternoon the “cultural ghetto.” Since public broadcasting had not yet begun, the burden of cultural respectability had to be carried by the networks. It was expected that a station’s license to make money would entail broadcasting programs in the “public’s interest, convenience and necessity.” It was assumed that culture was an American necessity. I don’t think commercial television was ever virginal, but it was prudent before it was prurient.

Later, when public broadcasting began, the commercial broadcasters were relieved. PBS would take over the responsibility of distributing the fine arts and sciences. CBS underwrote the building of the educational station in New York. It donated a complete New York studio with full equipment, and at the cost of millions, shepherded through a license for one more station in New York. It was a gracious gesture, but now not only could culture could be handed off to PBS, but the local CBS station had one less competing commercial channel in New York.

At the time the ratings came out just once a week. They were printed in what was called a Nielsen pocket piece. It measured only shows with commercials.

One day Sig Mickelson, the head of CBS News, came by my secretary’s desk and saw the Nielsen ratings piece. He was sharp with her.

“Perry is never to see the ratings. He and you are not hired to count the house. We do Adventure for other reasons.”

That is one of my fondest memories of the many fine men under whom I served.

Adventure was the precursor of the nature programs that have become staples of television broadcasting.

There were a lot of personal boundaries for me to erase.

I had always lived in big cities. Until the war I had seen the sky mostly as a backdrop behind buildings. So far as I knew, the sky could be square. As for the out-of-doors, I remember a vow of a soldier with whom I had shared a foxhole for a week. “When the war is over the only time I’m going outside is when I go from one building to another.” I agreed.

I recognized my incompetence quickly, and I cast my staff with a knowledgeable aide, Robert (Shad) Northshield.  In basic training Shad had taught me how to throw grenades properly. (Don’t bend the elbow, Wolff! Hurl it, don’t pitch it!) A print journalist, he had studied natural history. He was also the photography and zoo editor of The Chicago Sun Times.

Sometimes he appeared on screen, most notably on a live sequence devoted to friendly otters. While on the air the otter shat on Shad and bit him at the same time, and Northshield lost his commissioned officer composure.

Another wise choice was Jac Venza who became famous years later as the executive producer of Great Performances and the cultural czar of the Public Broadcasting Service.

The two men were at different poles.

Shad came to Jac and me one day. “We got to do a show on kidneys.”

“Why kidneys?”

“Because fish don’t piss.”

“Why don’t they piss, Shad?”

“Because the water flows through their gills and flushes the crap away. Until the fish got kidneys they had to stay in the water, so there couldn’t be animals living on land. We’d still be pissing in the ocean if the kidney hadn’t developed in the first fish that crawled on land, lungfish. The kidneys are an elaborate set of filters that screen out the poisons.”

Jac interrupted. “Elaborate filters?”

“Yes, Jac.”

“Perry, it has to be a Mondrian set. Mondrian’s paintings are filters. “

We found the kidney expert at the ichthyology department of the American Museum, and he explained the subject on the broadcast. Jac lost. The set was fishy.

CBS Studio Shoot

I wrote most of the segments, and at the beginning directed the live cameras. Later I hired help for both jobs.

There were practical boundaries between television and science. On the very first program an archeologist showed some of the Museum’s richest treasures—the Chibaya beaten gold pieces, so precious they were kept in a vault and were never on public view. The archeologist, Junius Bird, brought them by station wagon, carefully wrapped.

The union stagehand saw Dr. Bird bringing the artifacts into the studio. He was suspicious and confronted me.

“What is he carrying?”

“Beaten gold objects.”

“He’s carrying the props into the studio.”

“They can fall apart so easily!”

“He’s carrying the props into the studio. That’s a violation of the contract. Stagehands pick up the sets and the props. We deliver them. You’re in violation. Want to be written up?”

Dr. Bird got the masks into the studio, and the argument flared up again after the show.

Even today the beaten gold artifacts remain unseen and locked in the Museum’s vaults.

The next week my production manager called for delivery of sets and props. The stagehands were to go to Minnie in the basement room B2 of the American Museum. Minnie was told to let the union men handle all artifacts.

The live artifacts were rattlesnakes.

I had scheduled a sequence on herpetology. After some swearing the argument was settled amicably. The small scientist handled the props.

That same opening show contained the first of many disasters.

The most popular exhibit in the Museum was the Planetarium. The scientists in specialties less popular than astronomy called the Planetarium “our big theater,” but they tolerated it because it brought people into the building and provided some income.

We scheduled a visit to the site for the opening sequence. The segment was terrible.

The vastness of the heavens had to be reduced to the prevailing TV monitor size in 1953. The Universe was compacted to 18 inches, black and white.

As background music we played Gustav Holst’s The Planets but nothing was cosmic.

Years before I had been fascinated by the sciences, particularly astronomy. In the 1930s when the Depression made it seem that capitalism was a failure, my brother had persuaded me that Marxism was a scientific solution. Economics was a science, and an elite group of scientists could rule the world of finance. Science was pure, capitalism was base greed.  And the purest science was mathematics (I almost failed algebra my first semester, to Leon’s horror). Almost as pure was the movement of the universe. So I registered for an astronomy course at Northwestern, and sat at the end of the telescope, open to the cold winds of Lake Michigan. I froze.

I retreated from Marx. I am no longer awed by outer space.

Inner space, inexact science, life science as taught by the American Museum brings awe more slowly. It took time for me to appreciate the less exact disciplines. For example, I heard for the first time the word “ecology.” Over a film clip of plant and animal life in a garden the curator warned that the sun was the center of our environment and ecology was the study of the interrelationships between the species, and there might be trouble ahead.

I didn’t get it. I wasn’t yet worried about pollution, and so I cut the ecologist to ten minutes.

There were some scientific fakes in the Museum’s library films. They had a print of a snake film from a recommended Disney nature documentary. Snakes, writhing in an upright position in tempo with sinuous music. Shad was suspicious and called in a herpetologist. The elegant twisting of upright snakes was dismissed in a moment by the scientist.

“The snake is writhing because the sand he’s in has been heated almost to the boiling point. He’ll be dead in a few minutes.”

And then the perpetual questions that persists today: “How did the cameraman get the picture?” “Is he really inside the tree trunk looking at the bird’s eggs, or did they build a fake tree in the studio?” Once the audience asks itself this simple question, the fakery is often apparent.

Faking film, and the ethics of editing should be a required course.

Both institutions were good to us. The museum housed the CBS team and we ate “dinosaur stew” with the scientific staff at lunch in the common cafeteria.

At the beginning many of the scientists did not own or watch television. They patronized us. We were better tolerated after the scientists were astonished when strangers who had recognized them on-screen would thank and compliment them.

I knew when we were tacitly admitted when the most distinguished head of Mammalian Studies said, “ABC has a better test pattern at sign-off than CBS.” That meant he had stayed awake watching his screen until 2AM…and explained his red eyes the next morning.

As we moved into the second year the guards had a direction for strangers: “CBS used to be below the reptiles, but now they’re between the apes and man.”

We made an arrangement with museum-sanctioned expeditions. CBS split the cost of the film stock and processing, as well as half the tuition of short film course for the photographer-scientist. The Museum would give us access to their remarkable archives of past expeditions, but we would have to clear the rights with the owners.

Perry Wolff at CBS, Adventure Series

CBS gave me a staff, and $17,000 per week to produce the hour.

Some ten weeks in the season I went to the head of programming for CBS News and told him I had saved over $17,000.

“Wolff”, he said, “You have deprived the American audience of over $17,000 of production. You aren’t expected to make money.”

But he had trouble with a voucher we submitted entitled, Costs for Ants.

“Ants? Ants? You could have come to my kitchen in New Jersey and gotten as many as you wanted, free.”

We made a deal with the head of the Animal Behavior department who was studying the flow of army ants. At times tens of thousands of ants are dormant. At other times the insects move like a hungry river, a chain, devouring everything in its path. The group flows through the jungles of Central America.

I had approved the payment of the air ticket to a scientist, and I explained this to my financial superior.

I begged on the basis of the march of science. “The behavioral question is what triggers the flow of ants? Shall the river of ants be considered the basic biologic unit, or should the behavior of a single warrior ant be studied? I mean what about human behavior? Are we herds or are we individuals? It really was a hell of a segment, Lou.”

Mr. Stone was not impressed.

“Look. Suppose we change the voucher to “Ant Act” and the accountants will think of an insert on The Ed Sullivan Show. You know, two girls with antennae – feelers – coming out of their heads. Leading Sullivan on stage, with that goofy grin on his face. Cheap act at that price.”

The scientist who most impressed me was Dr. Harry Shapiro, Chairman of the Department of Anthropology. Tall, near-sighted, well dressed, he carried that green felt book bag that marked his generation of Harvard scholars. His speech was enthusiastic and simple. I nestled as closely as I could.

The American Museum came together when the scholars of 19th Century recognized the force of Darwin’s theory of evolution. The whole institution was based on the history of life on earth. The phylogenetic tree traced the many-million-year rise from single-celled creatures to that of our species, Homo sapiens. It was understood, if not said, that man was the culmination of evolution.

“The proper study of mankind is man,” said Alexander Pope.

(However an ichthyologist noted, “If a fish could draw the tree of life, there’d be a fish on top.”)

In its early days the museum considered some homo sapiens to be superior to other homo sapiens. A mild form of racism, but one that persisted too long. The anthropology departments particularly thought some ethnic groups were superior to others, and, while not scientifically provable, in practice rich New Englanders were at the top of the tree.

Harry Shapiro was professionally qualified to head the department in the 20th century, but the name Shapiro helped erase the past sins of earlier department heads. A Jewish chairman of anthropology was an apology and an act of contrition on the part of the Museum.

His specialty was physical anthropology, particularly the measurement of human skulls. A human skull fits neatly in a shoebox. Dr. Shapiro had many behind his desk chair. Like a Florsheim salesman, he would reach behind his head, catch the box by the lid, flip the lid back and pull out a human skull. He was opening a number of boxes one day when he made a remark that showed he was Jewish.

“You know the proscription that we Jews have against marrying a Gentile? When I was digging up and measuring skulls in the Holy Land I discovered why the rabbis were against it. It was that I found so many Hebrews had married Philistines. The cranial measurements show intermarriage flourished.”

I watched the competition between the two schools of anthropology—physical and ethnic. If Dr. Shapiro’s expertise was the study of skulls and bones, Dr. Margaret Mead’s skills were in describing the customs of societies. Each anthropologist was knowledgeable about the other’s field, but each was a specialist.

At the time Harry Shapiro had an advantage: he decided how the department would be housed.  As I passed his office one day, I heard him say, “Margaret, there are other anthropologists in this department. They need room, too!”

It was the first time I heard this elegant man raise his voice.

Johanis Lokus (Loponiu), Margaret Mead, Petrus Pomat, Raphael Manuwai, John Kilipak with Manus children, 1953.

The most difficult scientist I had to deal with was Dr. Mead, the most famous anthropologist of the time, and a goddess-to-be in the world of feminism.

Margaret Mead returned with a good deal of film footage from a second trip to the island of Manus in the Pacific. She was scheduled to make an appearance on Adventure. A previous husband had made a classic film of her visit to a tribe in Bali, Dance and Trance in Bali, but it was obvious she had not spent much time in the editing room. Her new footage was delivered to our editing room. Two editors and I screened rushes with her.

She was a small woman, older; imperious at one moment and friendly the next.

Her new Samoa material was edited by Jerry Bender who had never gone to college, had never heard of the most celebrated name at the American Museum, and went on to make a fortune in feature film sound editing. The dialog between the scientist and the editor grew tense. Film was a language she did not understand. Anthropology was a discipline new to Jerry.

I tried to act as a Rosetta Stone, but I couldn’t reach either.

“Mr. Bender you cannot put that picture there! I took it another day!” she said.

“Honey, I have to get from one moving shot to another. I need a still shot in between.”

“That man is not from this tribe!”

Jerry exploded “Dr. Mead, you take care of the fuckin’ anthropology, and I’ll take care of the fuckin fillum.”

I said, “Margaret, please give us an hour or two.”

When she came back we showed her the rough cut. It pleased her.

“Jerry, you’re right. You take care of the fillum, and I’ll take care of the anthropology.”

Previously, during the delivery of her daughter, the birth was filmed in close-up, but when she appeared on the set of Adventure she was concerned about her looks. I was directing, Charles Collingwood was the narrator, and Joe Papp was the floor director. Dr. Mead’s close-up was to be from a camera over the shoulder of the questioner. But on my screen she was in profile, not in full face. It took me a moment to understand why. She wasn’t looking at Collingwood; she was staring at her image on a floor monitor. She made eye contact only with herself.

“Papp,” I yelled, “Don’t let her see the monitors.”

There was scurrying and noise as the monitors were shifted. Finally the scientist had no choice but to look at the correspondent. Angrily, I thought.

She wasn’t angry the next time I saw her. In the months following she had received many compliments because of her first television appearance.

It was at a “dinosaur stew” lunch at the staff cafeteria. She thanked Jerry and me and brought me a fresh coffee when she went back for her own refill.

She said, “Harry Shapiro told me I looked young and wonderful on live TV. So did my daughter.”

 

Images

Center to Right: Perry Wolfe, Jac Venza and Mike Wallace, CBS Adventure Series, (photo: Landov), http://perrymilleradato.com/about/

CBS Studio Shoot, (photo: Landov), http://perrymilleradato.com/about/

Perry Wolff at CBS, Adventure Series, (photo: Landov), http://perrymilleradato.com/about/

Johanis Lokus (Loponiu), Margaret Mead, Petrus Pomat, Raphael Manuwai, John Kilipak with Manus children, 1953, https://www.loc.gov/exhibits/mead/field-manus.html

 

Feb 172017
 

Irna Phillips pictured dictating stories to her assistant, Rose Cooperman.

A few days before I was fired, my novel The Friend was published and released in Chicago. A small book party was held at a bookstore around the corner. The reviews in the Chicago papers had been good, but the attendance at the party was spotty: nobody from the radio station showed up. I had my family, a few friends and A.J. Liebling, the New Yorker critic who was writing a study of Chicago, The Second City. He could see I was disappointed at the small turnout. Liebling invited me to his apartment and fed me sardine sandwiches. He said something pertinent.

“Chicago is a great city to be from. Hemingway left, Hecht and McArthur left, and I’ll get out of here as quickly as I can. It’s not a town for writers.”

Tuulikki had been saying the same thing. When we were married I had promised to go to New York the following year. But it was approaching four years, and she was impatient.

At the time an old Army buddy, Arthur Peterson, was an actor in a soap opera The Guiding Light. He was indignant at the way I had been treated. He introduced me to Irna Phillips, the creator and sole writer of the serial.  By chance Miss Phillips wanted to try out a backup writer, and Art made much of my skills and my troubles with the Chicago police force.

Irna agreed to a paid tryout. She thought I should sit by for a week and watch her write. That way I could understand her writing style.

She didn’t write; she dictated. She was not a handsome woman, but she had fine, lanky legs. Dressed in a gauzy peignoir that reached only to her knees, she dictated all the parts to a gentle, understanding secretary who took shorthand notes.

Irna first played Meta, whose elegant accent was somewhere between Lake Forest, Illinois and three hundred miles west of England. Irna-Meta was elegant, impulsive, and too gentile for her German father.

“The Cherman Fahder had an eggscent dot was wery pronounced: aber he was kinly and gemüütlicht even to his elegant daughter,” she would say. Irna-Fadder was sad because Die Mutter of Irna-Meta had died, of course.

Irna played all the parts to the hilt, including the male suitor. And then, exactly on time just before the commercial, Irna imitated the announcer who breathlessly said, “Well!” or even “Well Well”. (Astonishment, required)

(Commercial)

Irna’s secretary would say, “What got into Meta today? What a way to talk to her father!”

Irna said, “I don’t understand that girl. She’d better watch out, or she’ll have some serious trouble!” Irna-Meta was not Irna Phillips.

The secretary typed out the script and sent it to New York where The Guiding Light was produced. At 12:15 pm Central Standard Time, Monday through Friday, the live broadcast was heard in the writer’s apartment. While Miss Phillips was content with the actress playing Meta, despite the many, many German refugees in New York, she disliked their accents.

She wanted someone whose eggscent was exactly like hers — someone “kinly and gemüüütilicht even to his elegant daughter. Die Irna-Mutter had died two seasons back.”

Irna was kindly and elegant to me. She outlined the plot for the next two weeks and sent me off to write some episodes. She also paid in advance.

I sent the trial episodes to her by mail and was asked to visit her in her Lake Shore Drive apartment.

“I am sorry”, she said. “But it won’t work out.”

“Why not Miss Phillips?”

“Perry, you made one error that I could correct. You advanced the plot on Monday. The plot must never advance on a Monday. That’s the day you review all the events of the week before to remind the audience and prepare them for the surprise on Tuesday.

“As I said I could take care of that. But there is something in your writing style that I know I could never correct.”

“Yes?”

“Perry, you rewrite. You are literary. You cannot dictate normal dialog because you rewrite and that is what makes it too literary.”

She continued. “I’ll tell you what I can do for you. There are going to be two deaths in the plot. (Two actors have quit for jobs in Hollywood.) You can write two funeral services for the Memorial Day programs.”

I did. An obituary for The Guiding Light for Mehta’s father. In real life, the actor had a profitable restaurant in Manhattan that gave him time to do the soap opera. The accented Mehta did a fifteen minute tribute to her fadder and cried very well. I don’t remember what other person character died or who read the second Guiding Light eulogy, but now I had enough money to go to New York and look for a job.

 

 

Jan 232017
 

1946 Piper J-3 Cub

As a returning veteran I was entitled to four more college years at government expense. I didn’t take the gift seriously until I heard the same educational benefits could be extended to aviation. I could learn to fly—at government expense. Because my eyes were so poor, I couldn’t become an airline pilot, but I could take some less ambitious flying lessons for next to nothing.

I thought we might go to war against the Russians. I didn’t want to walk anymore.

The bass player in the house orchestra, George Ramsby, sang hillbilly songs but had taught flying to many Air Force cadets. He offered to teach me for nothing, and the government would pay for the rental of the training plane, a J3 Piper Cub.

The plane’s top speed was 85 miles per hour. There was no gas gauge. A cork floated on its puny 12 gallon tank, and an inverted L-shape steel rod on the cork protruded to the cowling in front of the pilot. As the inverted L dropped lower, the aviator knew he needed a refill. On a day without headwinds the plane was good for 190 miles—about the distance from a Chicago suburb to Milwaukee.

It was a kite with wings, powered by a motorcycle engine.

What it recalled to me were my brother’s photographic albums of World War One. Spads, Nieuports, Fokkers. The training George gave me was not based on learning to fly from here to there; the object was to get Baron von Richtofen off my tail. I learned stalls, spins, figure 8’s. I had to fly a sharp 360-degree turn and hit my old prop wash when I completed the full circle.

Before I soloed, Tuulikki was nervous. She sat in the car and watched. George said that if she had one lesson she might calm down. He took her up, showed her how to make a banked turn with stick and rudder, and brought her down.

“Skee,” he said, “I know you have a good marriage, so I can tell you the truth. I can teach her to fly in half the time it will take me to teach you. She’s a dancer. She’s better coordinated than you.” Cruel, but accurate.

After some six hours of instruction, Ramsby put me into the pilot’s seat.

“Take her up, do a pattern and land her.”

Palwaukee airport was a sod field with two runways scratched as an X. I taxied to one, pushed the power to full and moved down the field. Without George in the cockpit the plane was lighter, and before I was ready, the Piper jumped into the air.

I had made myself fly.

I was in the air. Caesar, Napoleon, George Washington, Beethoven and Moses could not have elevated themselves to the heights I had reached. I was one with the Wright Brothers and Lindbergh.

Not quite. I was nervous and had a potbelly.

The Cub lands in a three point position. To land a plane as light as a Piper Cub the nose has to be high.  The two wheels and the tailskid have to touch at the same time. That means the landing stick has to push into the belly button and held firmly there. If the stick moves forward, the nose of the plane drops and the Piper picks up speed, wanting to rise again.

That’s what happened to me. My pot belly (which was small, but large enough) and my nervousness pushed the stick down and the plane rose skyward. I bounced twice and George waved at me to go around again.

I did and missed another landing, betrayed by my physique and neural connections. As I made the third approach, I saw Ramsby standing there with a shotgun. He threatened to shoot me down if I could not ground my emotions.

When he signed my logbook, certifying that I had soloed he commented, “If we go to war with the Russians, make sure you walk.”

 

Image

1946 Piper J-3 Cub: https://uk.pinterest.com/pin/340303315566521164/